What's a good secular argument against abortion?

What's a good secular argument against abortion?

What's a good secular argument against abortion?

slkusractshotindustries

I think is ending a life that has started. The argument is really, "When is a fetus considered alive and human to qualify killing it a murder." It's clouded... When you stab someone, and they are dead... you are stabbing a corpse and it is not alive. It wouldn't be murder. (Still get you in trouble though. ^^) Flip this around. When does the life start.. what can you stab before it's considered a murder? It's much more 'grey' on the beginning of the life aspect then it is on the end. It's easier to establish the end of a human life then it is the begining. When is bio matter considered to be human and protected under our laws? If someone (or something) doesn't realize they are being killed and doesn't feel pain, is it still ethical to end their/it's life? Should debate that hinges on religious concerns be a part of the argument? Those are the questions that define the issue...which is why it's so debated... So a secular reason would be... There is still much debate about the beginning of a human life. We find it to be murder to still kill a victim of a coma. Wouldn't be good to stay on the safe side and not kill things where there is still much debate it's alive or not? Does it sound ethical to stop life, even if it can't feel pain or comprehend it's life is about to end? That statement would be a good way to start. It's an argument that keeps religion out of a pro-life stance.

slkusractpalemalefriend

Hi. To be honest, I really couldn't come up with one. We have so much overpopulation already- so if a woman doesn't want to have a baby, why should she? We also have so many young people who are uneducated & unable to get jobs decent enough to raise children, so if they have unwanted babies, aren't we continuing the cycle of uneducated, unemployed people? There is so much child abuse out there, and a lot of that (not all) is aggravated by poverty, alcoholism, illiteracy, etc. Aren't we continuing that cycle if we prevent young women from those environments from having abortions? Poverty, being unable to afford to properly raise a child is a good reason not to have one. Coming from alcoholic parents (when we know there is a genetic component) and being already a drinker is not going to be a very good reason to have a baby. Being illiterate, thereby being unable to obtain gainful employment or help teach your child, is not a good reason to have a baby. I guess I can give you good secular reasons FOR abortion. --------------- To stretch my mind a bit: Perhaps someone, even in these situations, would have a baby who will grow up & rise above all the negatives in his/her life. Then that person may, indeed become an educated, intelligent person who might just do something wonderful for this planet. Maybe one or more of those children will become scientists who find cures for illnesses. Maybe one or more of those children will find ways to help the environment, thereby allowing humankind to exist longer on this planet. Or maybe one of these children will find great thing in outer space, allowing us to expand our horizons. And, finally, maybe one or more of those children will be able to figure out how to bring peace to our world. ----------------- Just because someone starts out in humble beginnings doesn't mean they will not thrive to be great men and women. I guess there are secular arguments for AND against abortion. Peace.

slkusract

There are arguments against abortion. They are too often used as arguments against choice.

slkusractKyle

Although this might sound harsh, its still a good argument: People who believe in abortion, why weren't they aborted? How can they support a value where they themselves could have died by it? Abortion takes life away. To those who support it, a good argument is to ask them, "Why weren't they aborted?" Out of love, they weren't aborted. It is time they did the same for others. Out of love, we began. Out of life, we live. Out of the pursuit of happiness, we grow. Love, Life, and the pursuit of happiness. It is for all, even those on the way. ...even for those on the way...

slkusractJaws

Well, many people belive that even before a child is born it is a life. And those braught up religiously are told that no life should be taken.

slkusractSirWilliam

.It stops the "life" process that has already begun... why plant a tree and then "pull it out"... "if" you don't want the tree, don't plant it........

Ask

Abortion

Popular Q&A

How many weeks pregnant is it until you cant get an abortion?
Where do you live? In most states throughout the USA, abortion is typically available up to 20 weeks, and sometimes it is available up to 24 weeks or later depending on where you live and what your circumstances are. In the UK, abortion is legal up to 24 weeks and is free through the NHS (National...

Is abortion legal in Arizona?
It is legal everywhere in the US.

What is far worse than this very tragic Colorado rampage?
You try telling that to the young mother shot through the neck and stomach only to find her daughter had been killed as well.

How do i get a judicial bypass for abortion?
Here is a good resource for starting to get a judicial bypass: http://cara.typepad.com/reproductive_rig... Under MI, it says you should call the circuit court in your county (find yours here: http://www.courts.michigan.gov/scao/serv... ) and tell them you want information on judicial bypass...

Pro-Choice Supporters: Should we raise the abortion limit to 28 weeks?
no 28 weeks is in the 3rd trimester- if the baby was born at this time there is a good chance of survival. It is undeniably a child by this time. You can feel movement, the baby has senses. http://3dpregnancy.parentsconnect.com/ca...